Gandhi was not killed
The air was heavy with pre-monsoon humidity, daily power cut had made matter worse. I decided to go for a stroll and found my way to the beach. There were some dark clouds but it didn’t threaten to rain atleast not for now maybe late in the evening. I found shade under the coconut groove just ahead where huge rocks protruded the sand as if reminding some abandoned ancient settlement- the kind you see in grainy pictures of school texts, beyond it the rocks gave way to fine white sand and restless ocean. From where I sat I had a clear view of balcony of a luxury hotel, where an old man sat on an easy chair, he was so thin that you could easily miss him if you don’t look carefully, a scrawny man with huge eyes that seem about to fall of from the socket. What made me give him my attention was the way he gawked the sea, he had astonishment frozen in his expression. Probably it was his maiden visit to the sea, I conjectured, few months back I saw group of Rajasthanis scrambling out of their tourist vehicle in varying level of bewilderment and disbelief.
Much later the man was still situated on the balcony, his forehead shone in the reflection of noon sun. Clutch of snow white hair on his pate was held captive to ocean breeze-they enacted its wishes, his clothes fluttered at the sudden gush of air, he looked surreal, maybe he was lost in some disturbing thoughts that he has lost track of time or he was too feeble to move. As I was thinking these his face turned slowly without him moving his body as if it were rotating on a hinge. It locked on to me, his piercing eyes couldn’t be ignored, very soon I felt awkward and cramped so thought of moving from his sight. Just at that very instance he raised his hands and waved. I looked around to make sure whether it was me he was trying to catch his attention. There wasn’t anyone around, I pointed finger towards me as if to ask “is it me you are calling?”, he nodded vehemently and indicated to come over. I vacillated. Why should I go? I don’t even know him. What if he had malevolent intentions? But then I argued, an elderly man may not pose much physical threat it is quite likely that he wanted some information or help regarding the place. What finally clinched my decision in favor was the prospect of visiting the interior of luxury hotel and maybe an offer of drinks (I will ask for beer, I decided), respite from heat. He waved again, and so I walked towards the main entrance of the hotel making sure not to hurry.
Soon I was in his presence. He lay on a comfortable large bed and appeared much older and pale. The room had many mirrors so that I could see him many times in different angles, I found it intimidating as well as oppressive, instantly I rued the decision of coming. He indicated with his eyes-that was much bigger and covered most of his face, to sit down on a chair that was placed to face him. It is as though everything was arranged and I was getting a sense of being trapped, a feeling that didn’t augur pleasant. He coughed and cleared his throat.
“I will be dying very soon” he said, despite discomfort his voice was strong and purposeful.
“Oh” I panicked “should I call an ambulance? You need some medicine?” I tried to get up to accentuate my concern.
“Soon is not now” he attempted a smile that vanished at the very instant “I want to tell you something that I haven’t told anyone, something that I have kept as a secret for last sixty years”. He seemed to be in a hurry to get to his concern. “I don’t have much time”.
“Why me?” I enquired. He nodded “I will tell you”. He spoke in a steady measured tone that hid the fact that he was in some physical pain.
“Because I don’t know you. You are a stranger. It is a promise that I shouldn’t be telling anyone, I have to keep it a secret. Telling you will lighten me, it has been burdening me for last many years. Since I don’t know you it’s like telling no one. I have spoken to myself many times but I still feel heavy with emotion. You will have to listen to me. Anyway nobody will believe you if you tell anyone, this secret will die with me”
“Really” I was getting interested and tried to make myself comfortable. The room was brightly lit and had every indication of luxury and opulence.
“Mahatma Gandhi did not die” his voice was heavy and betrayed an emotion that he seemed to hold back with great effort. His lips quivered, his eyes glistened and his face glowed as if he was in some revelation. “Mahatma Gandhi did not die” he repeated and immediately gasped for breath.
So there, I thought, the man is insane. I took pity on him and tried to appear sympathetic and mentally planned my exit from the place.
“Yes our comrades also believe that Subhash Chandra Bose is alive, hale and hearty sipping Russian tea. Some people even think that he lives as a mendicant in Himalayas. Investigations on these matters are still going on” I tried humor.
He gave a stern look, vein on his temple throbbing, his eyes almost maniacal, but when spoke he was very calm and controlled
“Don’t try that. This is not funny” he warned and continued “I am an old man, a very old man. Why would I be lying? I will die soon. Believe the man who is dying. Trust me. I have nothing to gain. Why would I lie I don’t even know you? What I am saying is true. Mahatma never died. This is what happened, the world doesn’t know about it doesn’t mean it is not true. If history has been written doesn’t make it true. I was witness to what happened on January 30. There is a history that is not written and only I know about it. I want someone to know about it before I die before it is too late” he steadied his voice that had started to bray. His finger shook he clutched them into a tightened fist.
These words had immediate impact on me and I sobered and was attentive to what he had to say, a sense of compassion had overcome me though I still harbored the thought that he was senile.
He cleared his phlegm filled throat and said
“I was one of the assistant of Mahatma Gandhi. I was a volunteer in the ashram from 1928. I was influenced by his thoughts and left home and became his follower. Like millions I believed in each word he said. I wrote them all in my notebook. I followed him on dandi march and spread his message to each village we visited on the village, to everyone around. You can see me in the film taken during dandi march, I am few feet behind mahatma with bag across my shoulder. You can look for me next time you watch it”. He stopped for a moment and asked me to open the cupboard next to where I sat, and take out a box. I was instructed to open the box. It had bundles of photographs carefully stacked-all black and white.
“You go through them and maybe you will understand me better” he said while he relaxed, continuous talking seemed to have tired him.
Almost all pictures were that of Gandhi taken on different occasions with different people over a period of what looked like about two decades (I am guessing this on account of association of different events and people in Gandhi’s life that is public memory, like many photos were taken around dandi march while some just about after independence) but one face popped up in each frame with constancy. It was a young man with bright eyes, wavy hair and pencil thin moustache.
He nodded “Nobody will believe that it’s me. Well you can say that I have seen what all life has to offer”. His face was half submerged in pillows, his thick eyebrows couldn’t hide the bulging eyes that looked grotesque. His lips were permanently sucked inside his mouth, his skin hung from his body as if it were melting. He struggled with his speech while I was engrossed in the content of the box. They were all there Nehru in deep thought, Patel with grim face, Sarojini Naidu managing a tired smile, Maulana Azad about to twirl his moustache, Mountbatten aloof and alone with a fake laugh…Most of these luminaries we have seen so many times in same photos on different occasion that it is etched in our collective memory, these photos shook them up a bit as if they came out alive for a moment changed their position and froze.
“For a follower of Gandhi you have adapted well to materialism!” the sarcasm was evident in my tone.
He was ready with his answer and said almost instantly “that is because I am a Gandhian, I am guilty of being a Gandhian” he was apologetic and anguished “It is the easiest and comfortable way to usurp Mahatma’s thought for personal gain, I plead guilty. We have made lot of money and influence in the name of Gandhi. We sold Gandhi”
“Yes recently even the grandson of Gandhi was found peddling a luxury pen in Gandhi’s name. Quite an audacious scoundrel, it is only getting crass and crude” I couldn’t help express my disgust.
“Gandhi has to be experienced, it is a way of life that seeks truth, learns and understands” as he was saying these my attention was back to the content of the box.
The box also contained postcard that were used for correspondence. It was unmistakable Gandhi’s handwriting- the familiar haphazard hurried way he wrote like doctor’s prescription, they were precise and to the point, some sentences curved at the end as if he wanted to save the space. Some had Sevagram Wardha scribbled on top right with dates. One postcard read “We can learn many things even from the spinning process. Real education is the development of character spinning is applied translations of Gita” another one chastised “Handwriting good but spinning not enough” while another was written with certain care “Internal cleanliness is the main thing to achieve. Love Bapu”. There was one that intriguingly read “You have written in a beautiful hand. I am surprised to hear from you that you don’t feel benefited by tub baths. I do not have any such case with me”. There were many more like “Keep a regular diary and jot down in it your ideas. Hiding one’s idea is also a theft”, “when the struggle is about to be launched I would like you to be present here: I shall call you at the earliest” and so on.
By now the man had gained my tremendous admiration. Here I was talking to someone who was a disciple and close confidant of Mahatma Gandhi himself, it was exhilarating. Suddenly I felt like having a closer look at him. He coughed, saliva dripped from the corner of his mouth, I cringed. He looked at me and smiled, his features were tender and soft “body deteriorates when you get old, it is the law of nature. Old gives way for young” he said and relapsed in his thoughts, I regretted my initial detest towards him. He coughed again took a deep breath and continued with his main deliberation
“Mahatma did not die he survived the bullets. I was there behind him at Birla house on that god forsaken day. You know he was never late but that day was different. He was unusually sad, all the killings and riots had affected him seriously. He would go silent for days and meditate. That day too he was silent for a long hours, and when he it was time for evening prayer I observed a faint smile on his face, he decided to walk barefoot in the grass instead of usual path to prayer ground. It seemed he knew he will be harmed but could not believe it. He never could understand violence. Reasons for violence were alien to him. I was behind him all the time, people folded their hands and crowded as he walked, they wanted to see him touch his feet. And then bullets were fired by someone- didn’t see him, my concern was mahatma. And I can say with no doubt in my mind that he said ‘ram hey ram’. I was one of those who held him, and I felt warm blood, we took him inside. People were all crying and nobody could believe that he was dead”. Here he took a long pause. His eyes were moist, he turned his face towards the open window. The ocean was flaming in the last flares of dipping sun, it seem about to explode.
“Are you all right” I asked his long pause had got me concerned. He murmured something and continued with some effort
“Mahatma did not die. People think he died but he did not. That night I was the one who was guarding his body. Late into the night when everyone was either half asleep or lost in mourning in the next room he got up”
“You mean Gandhi got up from dead?” I tried to confirm what I heard.
He sounded irritated “you are not listening. He never died. Late into the night I heard a voice ‘kalayanamoorthy you think I am dead?’ it was the Mahatma he had got up and pressed his fingers against his chest and said ‘I feel a terrible pain here’ and sat down against the wall ‘mahatma are you feeling fine?’ I asked. ‘Yes I am fine. I will not die yet. I am to live till the age of 125’ and asked for a glass of water. He drank it and walked away into the dark. He has visited me many times after that but told me to keep the visits and his whereabouts secret”
“But we know that his body was taken to rajghat in a long public procession watched by millions, I too have seen the video his body in funeral pyre and ashes taken around the country to be dispersed in sacred rivers” I confronted him with these facts.
“That was not him. He had walked away, he is alive. He has visited me many occasions through these years. He said he stays in the hills”
“Why would he stay in the hill?” I couldn’t help asking
“Because he wanted to get away from power from politics. India was now independent and he felt he had no use of himself in Delhi. He wanted to travel around the country and be with people. The government should start from the village he said ‘my work will be finished if I succeed in carrying conviction to the human family, that every man or woman, however weak in body, is the guardian of his or her self-respect and liberty. This defense avails, though the whole world may be against the individual resister’”
“You said he visits you?” I asked
“Yes every now and then just about midnight he appears from the dark ‘moorthy have you slept?’ ‘No mahatma I was waiting for you’ I say and feed him some fresh fruits. He always ate less”
“What do you talk?’ I was getting inquisitive.
“He spoke less and sat in the dark with eyes closed, deep in meditation, in contemplation. Sometimes he spoke few lines. A thought arising out of contemplation must be told, it reflects truth, truth must be told. It makes understanding easy. It makes world a better place” he halted to sneeze and wipe his face “mahatma told me once ‘there are not many fundamental truths, but there is only one fundamental truth which is Truth itself, otherwise known as Non-violence. Finite human being shall never know in its fullness Truth and love which is in itself infinite. But we do know enough for our guidance. We shall err, and sometimes grievously, in our application. But man is a self-governing being, and self-government necessarily includes the power as much to commit errors as to set them right as often as they are made’. He is aghast at growing religious intolerance around the world in recent times. He cannot understand why people would fight in the name of religion, he said ‘After long study and experience, I have come to the conclusion that all religions are true, all religions have some errors in them, all religions are almost as dear to me as my own Hinduism, in as much as all human beings should be as dear to me as one's own close relatives. My own veneration for other faiths is the same as that for my own faith. I exercise my judgement about every scripture, including the Gita. I cannot let a scriptural text supersede my reason’. He also considered lack of religion and materialism threat to humanity ‘there are some who in the egotism of their reason declare that they have nothing to do with religion. But it is like a man saying that he breathes but that he has no nose ... even a man who disowns religion cannot and does not live without religion". He also said ‘I reject any religious doctrine that does not appeal to reason and is in conflict with morality…man for instance, cannot be untruthful, cruel and incontinent and claim to have God on his side’”.
“You know Gandhi never died he is dying. Every time I see him he has diminished and has become very fragile. I cannot help wondering where the world is moving. Gandhi is dying everyday around us. You will tell everyone this will you not?. Will you not do that?” he wasn’t pleading, I didn’t know how to react so gave a feeble affirmation.
He sighed and turned his face. I was asked to leave. It had become dark and started to drizzle. My immediate concern was to avoid getting drenched. The traffic had become chaotic with power cut making the traffic signals dysfunctional. There were some skirmishes as drivers try to squeeze into the available space, invectives were exchanged. Solitary neem tree shook in gush of sudden wind, it made a noise that sounded as though it had let out a wail and hundreds of tears dropped down at one instance.
Next day they found the old man dead in his bed. He died in his sleep due to old age related causes, nothing unnatural in the death was reported. But what troubled me was the sentence which mentioned that he was found more than a day after he was dead.